Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. 24/7 Space News .




NUKEWARS
Report downplays Iran's missile punch
by Staff Writers
Beirut, Lebanon (UPI) May 11, 2010


Iran's nuclear chief could meet EU's Ashton in Turkey
Tehran (AFP) May 11, 2010 - Iran's top nuclear negotiator Saeed Jalili could hold talks with EU foreign affairs chief Catherine Ashton in Turkey, the Iranian foreign ministry spokesman said on Tuesday. "Ms Ashton had requested a meeting several times. Iran agreed to this but the date has not been set yet. About the venue, as Turkey suggested that it be held there, we do not see a problem with that," Ramin Mehmanparast said. He told reporters that Jalili, who is secretary of Iran's Supreme National Security Council, would represent Tehran in the talks.

Ashton said in Brussels on Monday that she was prepared to hold talk with Iranian leaders, but only about its controversial nuclear programme. "We should wait and see what issues she wants to discuss," Mehmanparast said, insisting that Iran's nuclear programme was a matter for discussion with the International Atomic Energy Agency. "If she wants to bring up international issues, we will examine them and the nuclear fuel swap has its own formula," the spokesman said.

Ashton asked Ankara to contact Iranian authorities and try to organise talks on behalf of the six world powers involved in efforts to persuade Tehran to suspend uranium enrichment, a spokesman in Brussels said. Iran is already under three sets of UN sanctions over its refusal to suspend the sensitive nuclear enrichment and risks further sanctions over its continued defiance. The West has long accused the Islamic republic of seeking to develop nuclear weapons under the guise of its civilian nuclear energy programme, charges Tehran denies. Iran has also dragged its feet on a UN-brokered deal presented in October that would see most of its low enriched uranium stockpile shipped out of the country to be further enriched into nuclear fuel for a Tehran research reactor.

The deal stalled after Iran insisted the two materials be exchanged simultaneously within its borders. Mehmanparast said on Tuesday that Iran had been discussing "a new formula" for the nuclear fuel swap with Turkey and Brazil -- both non-permanent members of the UN Security Council. The two countries are opposed to fresh sanctions against Iran and have stepped up efforts for a diplomatic solution to the nuclear standoff. Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip "Erdogan will be in Iran at the same time as the Brazilian President" Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, who is due to make an official visit to Tehran from May 16 to 17, the spokesman said. "Talks will be held" with both leaders on the nuclear fuel deal, he said.

Iran has deployed 200-300 Shehab-1 and Shehab-2 ballistic missiles that can hit the Gulf Arab states but the short-term threat Tehran's missile arsenal poses to these U.S.-allied countries and to Israel has been overstated.

That's the conclusion reached by the International Institute for Strategic Studies in London, a widely respected think tank, in a special report on Iran's missile program released Monday, although Iran has made "robust strides" in developing longer range weapons than it has at present.

"Iran's ballistic missiles could be used as a political weapon to wage a terror campaign against adversary cities," particularly in the Middle East, the report said. These would be armed with conventional high-explosive warheads.

"While such attacks might trigger fear, the expected casualties would be low -- probably less than a few hundred, even assuming that that Iran unleashed its entire ballistic missile arsenal and that the majority of the missiles penetrated missile defenses."

Most media coverage of the report, "Iran's Ballistic Missile Capabilities: A Net Assessment," has focused primarily on the threat of Iran producing intercontinental ballistic missiles that would threaten the United States and Europe. But the more immediate danger from current Iran's missile array is faced by Israel, and to a lesser extent Iran's Arab neighbors in the gulf.

The primary target, of course, is clearly Israel, which has threatened to launch pre-emptive strikes against Iran's nuclear program.

The Shehab-1 and 2 cannot reach Israel but the emerging solid-fuel Shehab-3B and the Sejjil-2, likely to be operational within three years, can.

"The military utility of Iran's ballistic missiles is severely limited because of their very poor accuracy," the report stressed. "The missiles would probably be incapable of shutting down critical military activities.

"The confident destruction of a single, fixed-point military target, for example, would require Iran to allocate a very significant percentage, if not all, of its missile inventory to one specific mission.

"Against large-area military targets, such as an airfield or seaport, Iran could conduct harassment attacks aimed at disrupting operations or causing damage at fuel storage depots, but the missiles would probably be incapable of shutting down critical military activities."

A lack of transport-erector-launchers "and the delays necessary to reload would also be limiting factors to any massive attack," the IISS noted.

This assessment is at odds with those disclosed by Israel's military and intelligence establishment and even some American analysts.

Some of these have estimated that in the event of a sustained Iranian missile bombardment, backed by barrages from Hezbollah in Lebanon, Hamas in the Gaza Strip, and possibly Syria as well, Israel would suffer extremely heavy casualties.

These don't differentiate between Iran's missiles and the short-range missiles and rockets fired by its allies, which being infinitely more numerous -- Israel claims Hezbollah alone has as many as 45,000 projectiles -- would be likely to inflict more casualties than Iran's conventional weapons.

The Tehran regime's drive to develop long-range missiles is being conducted "in tandem" with the nuclear project, the report said.

"The two programs appear to be connected, with the aim of giving Iran the capability to deliver nuclear warheads well beyond its borders, though Iran steadfastly denies any interest in nuclear weapons and claims that its missiles are strictly defensive in nature."

The report's authors, IISS analysts Mark Fitzgerald and Michael Elleman, argue that Iran's current missile arsenal isn't much use for conventional attacks or even biological or chemical warfare.

"The possibility of chemical or biological warhead use cannot be excluded, although Iran is not known to possess such weapons and has forsworn them by treaty," the report said.

"Even if arms with chemical or biological warheads, however, the missiles could not reliably and predictably deliver enough warfare agent over a wide enough area to stop an adversary's military operations."

In that scenario, Israel would presumably be capable of unleashing retaliatory salvos of its own Jericho-2 ballistic missiles against Iranian targets and these are deemed far more accurate than the Iranian weapons.

"Moreover," the report went on, "Iran has too few missiles, TELs and trained launch crews to sustain the delivery of chemical agent to the battlefield for more than a few hours."

But it added, "Nuclear warheads have a much stronger strategic logic and all of Tehran's ballistic missiles are inherently capable of a nuclear payload, if Iran is able to make a small enough bomb."

.


Related Links
Learn about nuclear weapons doctrine and defense at SpaceWar.com
Learn about missile defense at SpaceWar.com
All about missiles at SpaceWar.com
Learn about the Superpowers of the 21st Century at SpaceWar.com






Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle








NUKEWARS
Surprise dinner fails to break Iran nuclear deadlock
Washington (AFP) May 7, 2010
A surprise, high-profile UN dinner failed to break the deadlock with Iran over its nuclear plans as the United States called it a "missed opportunity" and kept up the pressure Friday for UN sanctions. The Obama administration also claimed that Iran's dinner invitation to all 15 UN Security Council members on Thursday is another sign that Tehran is worried about its international isolation an ... read more


NUKEWARS
LRO Team Helps Track Laser Signals To Russian Rover Mirror

Lunar Polar Craters May Be Electrified

Seed Bank For The Moon

Craters Around Lunar Poles Could Be Electrified

NUKEWARS
Mars500 European Crew Selected And Ready To Go

Opportunity Drives Twice This Week

New Martian Views From Orbiting Camera Show Diversity

Countdown begins to 520 day 'Mars mission'

NUKEWARS
Astronaut Takes Flag To Outer Space To Commemorate The Ilan Ramon Scholarship Project

'Starving yogi' astounds Indian scientists

NASA Tests Orion Launch Abort System

NASA Studies Find Omega-3 May Help Reduce Bone Loss

NUKEWARS
China Signs Up First Female Astronauts

China To Launch Second Lunar Probe This Year

China, Bolivia to build communications satellite

China To Complete Wenchang Space Center By 2015

NUKEWARS
Russian Space Freighter Undocked From ISS

Researchers To Send Bacteria Into Orbit Aboard Atlantis

Russian Space Freighter Ready To Leave Orbital Station

NASA And DARPA Seek Satellite Research Proposals For ISS

NUKEWARS
Soyuz Consultation Committee Sets Inaugural Launch For Fourth Quarter Of 2010

Integration Of Soyuz' First And Second Stages Is Complete

Arianespace Signs Contract With HUGHES To Launch Jupiter

Energia Overseas Limited Assumes DIP Financing For Sea Launch

NUKEWARS
Planet discovered lacking methane

'This Planet Tastes Funny,' According To Spitzer

Small, Ground-Based Telescope Images Three Exoplanets

Wet Rocky Planets A Dime A Dozen In The Milky Way

NUKEWARS
Google, Verizon working on tablet computer: WSJ

Beware phony 3-D as Hollywood cashes in

Designed Biomaterials Mimicking Biology

New Metamaterial Device May Lead To See-Through Cameras And Scanners




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement