Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. 24/7 Space News .




OPINION SPACE
Space Fantasy 2009
by Simon Mansfield
Gerroa NSW (SPX) Nov 14, 2008


Time to get real.

Are we heading into 1999 or 2009. Either way it's time for another space fantasy - this time from The Planetary Society who are advising the incoming US Administration that the Moon is the wrong destination goal and that Mars is actually the correct destination. Problem is, NASA has Buckley's chance of reaching the moon anytime in the next decade let alone Mars in the next 25 years.

The lunar program is going to get chopped and changed and delayed but the new administration for purely political reasons will continue to support a return to lunar strategy with a tactical play to the Mars Lobby by keeping the two linked.

While the rockets NASA is currently designing to go back to the moon with cannot be used to get to Mars without multiple launches for orbital assembly (which along with refueling depots is the only way to build a space faring civilization); many of the life support systems will be of use and that will be enough to keep the pretty picture exhibits humming with children on family holidays and school excursions.

NASA in its current form is cheap PR for both domestic consumption and international application.

Recent closed meetings have reportedly seen a clear preference among the political class to continue with the lunar strategy while eating the cost of a few more shuttle launches to close the much feared "launch gap".

The wild card is the new bloke who might have been the true maverick candidate but plays Mr Quiet guy as a tactical move to make people feel comfortable as he swans through the crowded lobby to the big seat.

Only time will tell what Obama truly means for US space policy, but real politics and hard nosed economics can only mean that the Fantasy of Mars will stay such for many decades to come. The most we can hope for in manned space is a better understanding of space infrastructure development - with practical goals like fuel depots and other technology enabling developments being placed at the core of any plans costing billions over the next decade.

The only nugget in The Planetary Society report was it's reference to Earth Observation which like the rest of the planet is the real cash cow in this solar system.

From a public policy perspective investing billions in earth observation over the next 4-8 years could save trillions if the skeptics are right and the planet is fine and on course for an ice age some 2000 years from now.

And the flip side works just as well. As we really do need to know if the goose is cooked and the planet is in trouble. If it is real we will need to take substantial actions to mitigate and adapt to climate change.

And somewhere in the middle we might just find that Man's impact is just what the terraformers recommend we do to mitigate the ice age a few thousand years from now. It takes science - and lot's of it - to answer these questions.

Two decades ago Bush Senior directed NASA in the wake of the first shuttle disaster and the emerging issue of global warming to invest in earth observation to study this issue and let the scientists do their job.

Twenty years later global warming is one of the biggest issues in the global public policy debate. It's time to solve this riddle and have the knowledge to enable the hard decisions to be taken that could cost trillions and change the course of human civilization.

The incoming administration would be wise to consider these issues when considering its space policy and invest in basic knowledge and infrastructure - both of which invariably pay for themselves by their very existence.

.


Related Links
Beyond the Moon: A New Roadmap for Human Space Exploration in the 21st Century (2.9 MB PDF)
Examining the Vision: Balancing Science and Exploration
Space Analysis and Space OpEds






Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle








OPINION SPACE
The Griffin Space Fantasy
Honolulu HI (SPX) May 05, 2007
The March 14 2007 issue of Aviation Week contained an article by NASA Administrator Mike Griffin which apparently is the most detailed statement yet of his long-range plans. In this article and related press interviews, Griffin makes a case that NASA is not really as underfunded as many critics say, and that the US can afford three major space projects on the scale of Project Apollo over the next 50 years without major budget increases. ... read more


OPINION SPACE
Michelin Develops Lunar Wheel For NASA Moon Rover Vehicles

NASA Restores Historic Lunar Orbiter Image

India Rejoices Over Moon Probe Landing

US space-funeral company plans to launch lunar cemetery

OPINION SPACE
Mars Rover Team Sets Low-Power Plan For Spirit

Planetary Society Steps Beyond Moon For Roadmap To Space

India to take second moon shot by 2012, eyes Mars

Controllers Cheer As Data Arrive from NASA's Spirit Rover

OPINION SPACE
Kazakh Astronaut To Fly To ISS, Russian Hopeful Grounded

Space Researchers Developing Tool To Help Disoriented Pilots

Volan Escape System To Rescue Space Crews

CU-Boulder To Launch Butterfly, Spider K-12 Experiments

OPINION SPACE
The Chinese Space Industry Set For Take Off

China Puts Two Satellites Into Orbit

Souped-Up Rockets For Shenzhou

China Successfully Launches Research Satellites

OPINION SPACE
Shuttle crew to outfit living quarters on space station

Progress Cargo Module To Undock From ISS Friday

Two US astronauts to cast votes from space

Expedition 17 Set To Undock Today

OPINION SPACE
Sea Launch Prepares For Launch Of SICRAL 1B

Ariane 5 Is Readied For Arianespace's Initial Mission Of 2009

ILS Proton Successfully Launches ASTRA 1M Satellite

Russia Set To Launch SES Telecoms Satellite

OPINION SPACE
Seeing A Distant Planet

Hubble Snaps Exoplanet Orbiting Nearby Star

Dusty Shock Waves Generate Planet Ingredients

MIT Researchers Find Clues To Planets' Birth

OPINION SPACE
NigComSat-1 Fails To Work Due To Technical Error

Traffic Management In Outer Space

Military Weather Satellite Achieves Five Years On Orbit

Imaging software makes bridges safer




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement