Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. 24/7 Space News .




SUPERPOWERS
Outside View: Lyndon W. Obama
by Harlan Ullman
Washington (UPI) Apr 17, 2013


disclaimer: image is for illustration purposes only

The shadow of North Korea's latest provocations for the moment has obscured Iran and its nuclear ambitions. Another war on the Korean Peninsula would be a disaster for the Korean people even though the military defeat of the North that is sure to follow would no doubt end the Kim ruling dynasty.

That said, Iran remains a smoldering issue which, unlike North Korea, isn't posturing itself for war.

Any decision to use military force against Iran has been deferred thanks to U.S. President Barack Obama's successful visit to Israel last month. But herein rests a familiar lament for U.S. policy: making war for the wrong reasons. Of course, if North Korea attacks first, we have no choice but in choosing to make elective war, perhaps the United States has a defective gene in its national DNA.

Fifty years ago next year, Lyndon Johnson used the pretext of the Gulf of Tonkin incident for a de facto declaration of war against North Vietnam. A local naval commander ordered his patrol boats to attack USS Maddox on the mistaken assumption that the destroyer was abetting a clandestine naval raid against North Vietnam, about which Maddox was completely unaware.

Some 60,000 American and many more Vietnamese lives were lost in the quest to bear any burden and pay any price to defend freedom as President John Kennedy promised in his inaugural address in January 1961. Tragically, Johnson took that commitment too seriously. America blundered into what became the Vietnam quagmire.

Thirty-nine years after the Tonkin Gulf episode, President George W. Bush launched his war into Iraq for the purpose of removing Saddam Hussein who, CIA Director George Tenet said, not only had links with al-Qaida, it was a "slam dunk" that Saddam had weapons of mass destruction. That was reiterated by Vice President Dick Cheney who frequently asserted Saddam had nuclear bombs.

Almost midway between these two wars, the Reagan administration intervened in Grenada in late October 1983 following a military coup in which Prime Minister Maurice Bishop was killed. The arguments for the military invasion were fear of a Cuban/Soviet takeover of the island and specifically the building of a 9,000-foot runway from which Soviet aircraft could threaten America's East Coast. The pretext was assuring the safety of U.S. students attending the island's St. Georges' medical school from capture or worse at the hands of the Cubans or new government.

The assault came just after the Marine Barracks in Beirut was blown up and 241 Marines killed. After the invasion was under way, the commander, Vice Admiral Joseph Metcalf, repeatedly and understandably was asked about the safety of the students, which was his top priority, crisply responded to Washington that none was in danger and thus there was little urgency in getting forces to the medical school before securing the island.

Worse, the strategic runway had been under discussion for decades as a tourist magnet and the prime contractor was the British firm Plessey whose owners were fiercely anti-Soviet and highly capitalist employing the cheapest Cuban labor.

Operation Urgent Fury was a near disaster underscoring the inability then of the four U.S. military services to operate together. Fortunately, that flaw was corrected but the invasion was based on mistaken judgments.

What about Iran? First, assuming Korea quiets down, Obama would be well advised to revisit why the U.S. blundered so badly in Vietnam and Iraq the second time, arguably the two greatest foreign policy misjudgments in its history. Grenada offers further evidence of gross misjudgment in the rush to use military force even though it was a sideshow.

Some will argue that Vietnam and Iraq were largely intelligence failures. While intelligence did fail, responsibility, culpability and accountability fell centrally on the White House and the president. The truth was either not relevant or expediently manipulated for cynical political purposes.

In Vietnam, as Johnson famously argued, communism had to be halted on the Mekong and not the Mississippi once the Asian dominoes fell. Unlike the first Iraq war when Saddam had invaded a neighbor and had to be evicted, the raison d'etat was democratization of Iraq that would change the geostrategic landscape of the Middle East. Saddam's links with al-Qaida and the certainty of his stocks of WMD were fabrications for war.

It is seductive to make the case to disarm Iran of its nuclear capacity. The ayatollahs are irrational and cannot be trusted. A Shiite bomb will beget a Sunni weapon. The region will be destabilized. And Iran's radicalism will spread.

Iran may indeed have nuclear aspirations. After all, what is the best way to deter the United States, the West and Israel all of whom have nuclear weapons? Yet, history repeatedly demonstrates American vulnerability to a rogue gene in getting it very wrong. Mr. President, we hope you are listening.

(Harlan Ullman is chairman of the Killowen Group, which advises leaders of government and business, and senior adviser at Washington's Atlantic Council.)

(United Press International's "Outside View" commentaries are written by outside contributors who specialize in a variety of important issues. The views expressed do not necessarily reflect those of United Press International. In the interests of creating an open forum, original submissions are invited.)

.


Related Links
Learn about the Superpowers of the 21st Century at SpaceWar.com
Learn about nuclear weapons doctrine and defense at SpaceWar.com






Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle








SUPERPOWERS
US warship in Southeast Asia gives punch to US Asian 'pivot'
Singapore (AFP) April 18, 2013
A US warship designed to fight in coastal areas arrived Thursday in Singapore for its Southeast Asian deployment, underlining President Barack Obama's new strategic focus on Asia. The deployment of the USS Freedom comes at a time of heightened tensions on the Korean Peninsula and as China publicly flexes its naval muscle in the South China Sea, where it has competing territorial claims with ... read more


SUPERPOWERS
Characterizing The Lunar Radiation Environment

Russia rekindles Moon exploration program, intends setting up first human outposts there

Pre-existing mineralogy may survive lunar impacts

Lunar cycle determines hunting behaviour of nocturnal gulls

SUPERPOWERS
Accurate pointing by Curiosity

NASA Mars Orbiter Images May Show 1971 Soviet Lander

Opportunity is in position for solar conjunction at 'Cape York' on the rim of Endeavour Crater

NASA spacecraft may have spotted pieces of Soviet spacecraft on Mars

SUPERPOWERS
Testing Spacesuits in Antarctica, part 1

Obama's budget would boost science, health

Underwater for outer space

NASA Celebrates Four Decades of Plucky Pioneer 11

SUPERPOWERS
Shenzhou's Shadow Crew

Shenzhou 10 sent to launch site

China's Next Women Astronauts

Shenzhou 10 - Next Stop: Jiuquan

SUPERPOWERS
UH Engineering Researcher's Theories to be Tested Aboard ISS

Unmanned Russian space freighter leaves space station toward fiery end

Europe sets June 5 for launch of space freighter

Spooky action at a distance aboard the ISS

SUPERPOWERS
Launch pad problem scrubs launch of Antares rocket for NASA

ILS Proton Launches Anik G1 for Telesat

Ukraine aims to accelerate space industry development

Payload integration is underway for Vega's second mission from the Spaceport

SUPERPOWERS
Astronomers find most Earth-like planets yet

Can One Buy the Right to Name a Planet?

Retired Star Found With Planets And Debris Disc

The Great Exoplanet Debate

SUPERPOWERS
Softening steel problem expands computer model applications

New material gets itself into shape

For the very first time, two spacecraft will fly in formation with millimeter precision

High pressure gold nanocrystal structure revealed




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement